Covered home entrance with a hardwood door, cream stucco, basalt paving, and a flowering tree above two bird's-nest ferns.

Wailuku's Next Year of Theater Runs Through a Black Box on Main Street

By late October, all nine performances of A Streetcar Named Desire at MAPA's Naylor Theatre showed sold out on the box office page, with a waitlist link next to each date. Opening night is Friday, November 20. A few blocks away on Market Street, Maui County has budgeted about $3.8 million to restore the roof of the ʻĪao Theater, and the work is expected to close Maui's oldest stage for several months sometime in 2027.

Over the next year, more of Wailuku's live theater will happen in a much smaller room, and the ʻĪao closure hasn't even started yet.

A sold-out run in a room built to flex

The Naylor Theatre sits at 2027 Main Street, in the building MAPA identifies as the former National Dollar Store. According to Maui Now, it is a 12,000-square-foot, $15 million project that began in 2016. Government agencies put in about $10 million of that: $350,000 from Maui County, $1.1 million from the state and roughly $8.5 million in federal money. Philanthropist Susan Naylor's $1 million pledge in 2022 was the largest private gift. The debut production, Cabaret, played nine performances from November 14 to 30, ahead of the formal opening on January 7, 2026, when the theater was named for the Naylor family.

The building gives MAPA its first permanent home. The organization started in 1974 as Maui Youth Theater, an after-school drama program founded by former Baldwin High School teacher Linda Takita, and took the MAPA name in 1990. Eric Gilliom grew up in that program, and he told Maui Now on opening night that "the flexibility of the space is unparalleled" and predicted it would "become the Jewel of Wailuku."

That flexibility shapes how many people get in. The Naylor is a true black box, with black walls and a flat floor. The stage can face the audience from any of three walls, and the room is large enough to seat an audience in the round. The building also holds a lobby, a green room, a scene shop and two rehearsal studios. Earlier this year The Revolutionists used an 84-seat in-the-round layout, and Frozen was planned at 175 seats per show.

The Streetcar listing does not say which layout it uses. Even at the larger 175-seat setup, though, nine performances top out at about 1,575 tickets. The ʻĪao Theater seats 413, so it holds more people over four nights. A run that sells out at the Naylor sells out fast because the room is small.

The bigger house, and the roof over it

The ʻĪao Theater opened on August 22, 1928, as a movie house and live-performance venue with 702 seats. Today it seats 413. Maui OnStage runs it, and the company's Kristi Scott told The Maui News in September that the timing is still open:

"The county is going to repair the roof of the almost 100-year-old building. In order to do that, we'll have to shut down. We don't have a date, but we were told it would be within 2027. It's a little hard to program not knowing what's going on."

In the same article, Scott said the company is "good up through the end of this year" and is working on alternate venues. She added that the closure means lost rental revenue. No replacement venue had been announced as of late October.

The company's fundraiser has already moved off the property. Maui OnStage now lists its Raise the Roof fundraiser for a new date of November 21 at Ocean Vodka Organic Farm and Distillery. When The Maui News previewed it for its original September 26 date, tickets were $225. Guests were invited to dress in "construction wear or festive aloha" and guess the company's coming season from clues in the décor and costumes.

How the two stages compare right now

ʻĪao Theater The Naylor Theatre
Address 68 N. Market St. 2027 Main St.
Opened August 22, 1928 Formal opening January 7, 2026, after a November debut run
Seats 413 84 in the round; 175 in another layout
Run by Maui OnStage Maui Academy of Performing Arts
Status heading into 2027 Roof restoration expected to close it for several months; no date set Second season under way

The calendar between now and summer

Until the county sets a date, ʻĪao stays on the calendar alongside the Naylor. MAPA calls 2026–27 its second season in the Naylor Theatre. Here are the dates on both stages through next summer:

  1. Friday, November 6: Wailuku First Friday on Market Street, 6 to 9 p.m.
  2. November 20 to December 6: A Streetcar Named Desire at the Naylor, directed by Sally Sefton. Shows are at 7:30 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays and 3 p.m. on Sundays, and the runtime is 2 hours 45 minutes. Tickets run $17.50 to $45, and every seat is $25 on the "Mahalo Saturday" nights of November 21 and 28.
  3. Saturday, November 21: Maui OnStage's Raise the Roof fundraiser at Ocean Vodka.
  4. February 5 to 21, 2027: The Last Five Years, a two-person musical, at the Naylor.
  5. February 14, 2027: An afternoon with David Sedaris, booked as a facility rental through Maui OnStage.
  6. April 23 to May 9, 2027: POTUS at the Naylor.
  7. July 15 to 25, 2027: Hadestown: Teen Edition at the Naylor.

Maui OnStage also runs a series called One Night Only, which it describes as a free, bare-bones stage for community presenters. The presenters choose and rehearse their own work, and Maui OnStage provides the stage. If you have a piece you've wanted to put in front of an audience, the 413-seat house has a limited number of 2027 dates before the roof work begins.

The Streetcar waitlist is the realistic way in for this run. MAPA's ticketing page has a separate waitlist link for each performance. MAPA also posts a content advisory for the play, which is set in the late 1940s and depicts alcohol use and domestic violence, along with references to sexual assault and suicide.

December 4 is the night to plan around

One Streetcar performance falls on First Friday, and MAPA put a warning about it right on the box office page. For Friday, December 4, the company asks patrons to allow extra time for traffic and parking. It recommends arriving an hour or two early and eating dinner in Wailuku first, "because the Wailuku Garage is often full by 7 PM on First Friday."

Here are the garage details for an evening show. According to Park Maui, the first floor of the garage at 30 N. Church St. is public parking. Upper floors are for permit holders. Visitor parking costs $1 an hour, up to $10 a day, during paid hours of 8 a.m. to 6 p.m., and drivers with a Hawaiʻi license get the first two hours free. A May 2026 notice from Wailuku First Friday says garage parking is free after 6 p.m. For a 7:30 curtain, cost isn't the issue. Getting a space before 7 is.

On North Church Street you'll also pass the construction site for Hālau of ʻŌiwi Art, a Hawaiian cultural center at the corner of Vineyard and North Church. An October 9 update reported plumbing excavation, column formwork, structural steel and concrete work, with completion scheduled for April 19, 2027, subject to change.

For dinner before the show, two Main Street restaurants have posted hours that fit the schedule:

  • A Saigon Café, 1792 Main St., serves Vietnamese food daily from 11 a.m. to 8:30 p.m.
  • Tiffany's Restaurant & Bar, 1424 Lower Main St., is open until 10 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays and until 9 p.m. on Sundays, which also covers dinner after a 3 p.m. matinee.

Eat early and park before 7, and the December 4 show can be a relaxed evening on Main Street.

I'm watching for the county to set a start date for the ʻĪao roof work and for Maui OnStage to name a temporary venue, and both will change the Wailuku calendar for 2027. If you're thinking about a Wailuku home within walking distance of Market and Main, Dee Garnes is happy to walk those blocks with you on a show night. Schedule a private consultation and we'll plan it around the next curtain.

Work With Dee

Get assistance in determining the current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

Follow Me on Instagram