Through the first ten months of 2025, a single-family house in Wailuku sold for more than one in Pukalani. Through the first ten months of 2026, it sold for about $241,500 less. The Realtors Association of Maui year-to-date report, current as of November 2, 2026, has Wailuku's median single-family sale price for January through October at $1,007,500, down 16.0% from $1,200,000 over the same months of 2025. Over the same January-to-October window, Pukalani's median rose 9.1% to $1,249,000.
Wailuku's decline came with fewer closings, its average price fell almost as far as its median, and the large new supply planned for central Maui is still mostly ahead on the calendar. For a buyer comparing central Maui with Upcountry and the rest of the island, that makes the timing of a Wailuku purchase a different question from the one the headline median suggests.
One month of Wailuku sales is a small sample
The latest single month is the number most likely to turn up in a portal widget, and it is the least reliable. In October 2026, nine single-family homes closed in Wailuku at a median of $820,000. In September 2026, six closed at a median of $1,005,000. In October 2025, fifteen closed at $1,192,500. With six or nine sales, one or two closings at either end of the range can move the median by six figures from one month to the next.
The ten-month figure is steadier. Wailuku recorded 100 single-family closings from January through October 2026, against 115 in the same period of 2025. One hundred sales is enough to show a trend, and the trend is down.
The average fell almost as far as the median
A median can fall because the expensive homes stop selling while everything else holds, and when that happens the average usually drops further than the median. In Wailuku's 2026 numbers, the average sale price over January through October fell 15.3%, from $1,179,937 to $999,414, nearly the same share as the median's 16.0% drop. Two measures falling by nearly the same share is more consistent with a broad decline than with a handful of missing high-end sales.
The island as a whole looks different. Across all of Maui, the January-to-October single-family median fell 6.8% to $1,211,500, while the average fell 9.7% to $1,638,072. Islandwide, the average fell further than the median, which points to more of the decline sitting with the most expensive sales. Wailuku's two measures moved together.
Here is how Wailuku compares with nearby areas over the same ten months:
| Area | Closings, Jan–Oct 2025 | Closings, Jan–Oct 2026 | Median, Jan–Oct 2025 | Median, Jan–Oct 2026 | Change in median |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wailuku | 115 | 100 | $1,200,000 | $1,007,500 | -16.0% |
| Pukalani | 20 | 23 | $1,145,000 | $1,249,000 | +9.1% |
| Makawao/Olinda/Haliimaile | 60 | 51 | $1,365,000 | $1,560,000 | +14.3% |
| Kula/Ulupalakua/Kanaio | 47 | 55 | $1,600,000 | $1,530,000 | -4.4% |
| All of Maui | 591 | 596 | $1,300,000 | $1,211,500 | -6.8% |
In 2025, Wailuku's ten-month median was $100,000 below the island figure. In 2026, the gap is $204,000. Through the first ten months of the year, the discount for buying in central Maui roughly doubled.
Fewer sales, and no flood of new houses
If a wave of new homes had caused the drop, Wailuku would show more closings at lower prices. It shows fewer. Total single-family dollar volume in Wailuku from January through October 2026 was $99.9 million, down 26.4% from $135.7 million in the same months of 2025. Fewer buyers paid less per house.
The island's pace has slowed too. In October 2026, single-family homes across Maui averaged 148 days on market until sale, up from 138 in October 2025, and new listings fell to 81 from 105. RAM's area table does not break days on market out for Wailuku alone, so the island figure is the closest available guide to how long a central Maui listing should be expected to sit.
The softening is not new to this fall. In July 2025, The Maui News reported that the Realtors Association of Maui's president attributed the market's hesitation to uncertainty, including worries about job security, and said sellers were cutting asking prices without getting the prices they wanted. The 2026 Wailuku figures fit a market where hesitant demand, not extra supply, did the work.
What a brand-new house in Kehalani costs
New construction in Wailuku is not priced near the resale median. At Anuhea at Kehalani, a 164-home community from Towne Island Homes with six floor plans, the available home on the developer's page is the furnished Lot 7 model, an Aheahe plan with three bedrooms, two baths, a two-car garage and 1,529 square feet of living space on a 9,792-square-foot lot, listed at $1,512,000. The page carries no date, so the price and availability are a snapshot that can change.
That asking price is about $504,500 above Wailuku's ten-month resale median. A new single-story home on a large Kehalani lot is a different product from much of the resale stock, and its asking price sits well above where Wailuku resales closed this year.
The new supply runs on a calendar measured in years
The project that could change central Maui's housing supply is Waikapū Country Town. As Maui Now reported on November 14, 2026, developer Mike Atherton's Waikapū Properties LLC is preparing to break ground on a 1,433-unit project with 500 workforce units, 933 market-rate units, 200,000 square feet of retail space and 910 acres of agricultural preserve. Atherton told the Hawaiʻi Journalism Initiative, in that Maui Now story, that he expected construction to be underway "more or less in 60 days," which points to early 2027.
The order of work matters for anyone trying to time a purchase. Atherton said in the same report that infrastructure such as water lines comes first, then the affordable housing, then the elementary school, and he estimated the first affordable homes would be ready in about two years. The report gave no date for the 933 market-rate homes. The state's housing finance agency, HHFDC, approved WCT Partners, LLC for a $17 million interim loan for Phase 1 regional infrastructure, and the governor approved release of that money in August 2026.
Atherton began planning the project in 2004, and the Maui County Council approved it in 2019. It can go forward now because a 2022 agreement with the county lets it connect to the existing wastewater system in Kahului. The new Central Maui wastewater plant meant to serve the region's growth now carries a $342.8 million estimate and is expected to be operating in 2029. The Maui Planning Commission voted 6-0 to recommend the land use changes for its 15-acre site, and the County Council has the final say. The planned Central Maui elementary and middle school on the Waikapū land would open its first phase in 2031.
Put the dates side by side and the 2026 discount in Wailuku came well ahead of any of this housing. The homes that would add real supply to central Maui come after it, in stages, starting about two years out by the developer's own estimate.
What the 2026 numbers mean for a buyer
For a buyer choosing between Wailuku and Upcountry, the two markets moved in opposite directions this year. A buyer who would have paid a Pukalani-level price in Wailuku in 2025 is now looking at a median about $241,500 below Pukalani's for January through October 2026. That is a real change in relative value. Waikapū's homes did not cause it, so their arrival is not what it depends on.
For a buyer choosing between resale and new construction inside Wailuku, the gap is wide. A furnished Kehalani model at $1,512,000 and a resale house near the $1,007,500 median are different decisions, and the comparison worth making is house to house and lot to lot, not against the area median.
For a seller, the ten-month figures show a market with fewer closings and longer island-wide marketing times. Pricing from 2025 comparable sales would start from a level Wailuku buyers did not pay in 2026.
None of this predicts where Wailuku prices go next. It shows where they stood on November 2, 2026. Through October, the central Maui discount widened while closings fell. A Wailuku home valuation built on this year's closings, not last year's, is the starting point for either side of a deal. More context sits on the Wailuku neighborhood page and in the latest Maui market report.
If you're weighing a Wailuku house against Pukalani or Kahului, or deciding whether a Kehalani new build is worth its premium over resale, Dee Garnes can go through this year's closed Wailuku sales with you. Schedule a private consultation and bring the listings you're considering. We'll compare each one with what similar Wailuku homes actually sold for in 2026.